“You Can See Everything” begins as a documentary about Elizabeth Holmes* and her husband, Billy Evans, then keeps complicating questions of truth, storytelling, deceit, and audience. It’s nearly three hours long, but I couldn’t get enough. Entertainment is part of what the movie examines.
Is this a documentary or something else? It’s absurd, so it’s hard to categorize or explain.
I read enough beforehand to know it would be about more than Holmes’s character or guilt. But I still waited at first for a hard-hitting evil-Holmes reveal. Then it seemed like both Holmes and Evans were bad.
How much of that is them, and how much is Nathan Fielder? His presence seems to make every encounter harder to interpret.
For a while, the movie invites us to sympathize with Holmes—maybe she is a fraud but also a victim of controlling men. Then it raises the possibility that this sympathetic characterization is actually being cultivated by Holmes and Evans. As you watch, Evans looks worse and worse—controlling, greedy, narcissistic, and manipulative. But is that him or the character he’s supposed to play in Holmes’s story?
Then we see Holmes, Evans, and Fielder watching “The Dropout,” the miniseries about Holmes’s rise and fall, in which Amanda Seyfried plays Holmes. The melodrama seems ridiculous. Was the series that embarrassing? How could that show be popular? There’s obviously a gap between the story people think they know and what actually happened. It seems.
The craziest turn for me was when Holmes goes to prison. It occurred to me that maybe life had been suspended for her and Evans all along: she knew she was going to prison, so a sense of normalcy was already out of reach. Maybe this could explain the craziness of restarting Theranos.
And nothing-is-ever-normal Fielder was there.
Flashforward. She’s in prison, and Evans, now seeming erratic and unstable, still tries to get Theranos going again. And he’s cagey about supporting a billboard campaign and silly theater production about Holmes’s story and her innocence.
Some of the scenes of him with Fielder look staged to me—the camera is steady, as if on a tripod, and the two men stay in frame. There’s an obvious tension between them, and I can’t help wondering whether there would be more nervous movement—more pacing, shifting, turning—if the cameras weren’t there.
Fielder eventually brings Seyfried into the story by showing her the footage of Holmes watching Seyfried play her. Seyfried seems embarrassed but is now part of the movie. She and Fielder begin staging reenactments of events, including some that weren’t filmed, and Fielder scripts those scenes from memory.
So many reenactments happen that my head was spinning. What was true? How much collaboration was there? The movie brings up questions of records, video evidence, and memory, and how much any of them can seem true.
One key dispute is about a quote attributed to Holmes in an article in The New York Times: “They aren’t playing me. They are playing a character I created.” Holmes and Evans question whether she said it. Fielder makes the dispute feel central to the movie’s larger puzzle: who is telling the story, and who gets to control it?
Fielder also tells Seyfried that before filming officially began, he, Oppenheim, and two A24 producers met with Holmes and Evans. Holmes left the room, and then Evans asked for a share of the profits. Holmes later jokes on film that she isn’t being paid to participate. Now we have questions about creative control—how much belongs to Holmes, to Evans, to Fielder, to A24? Why is Fielder even there?
Evans says they (he and Holmes) thought Fielder might be open to something besides the established story. That makes sense! His work often plays with performance and unreality.
Holmes appears (or tries to appear) sympathetic, authentic, and soft; Fielder comes across as stiff and socially awkward. There’s a lot of richness in that pairing. I even wondered if Fielder was going along with the scam because it made for good entertainment. But he does seem to look for Holmes’s innocence. Then again, maybe that’s his way of showing how people construct a narrative when faced with in-your-face lies and deception.
I don’t think the movie is interested in whether Holmes is a liar or a victim; it shows how we decide what story we’re watching.
It doesn’t fit neatly into a genre. It’s part documentary, part comedy, and something else. The biggest joke may be the teaser that was released before the movie, when Fielder looks into a famous liar’s eyes and asks if she’s being real. Is the movie trying to answer that question—or showing us how readily we get pulled into asking it?
*Holmes founded Theranos, the blood-testing company at the center of the movie. A jury convicted her of one conspiracy count and three counts of wire fraud related to investors; she was sentenced to 135 months in prison.
Notes:
- Holmes and Evans were trying to restart Theranos. Crazy. We see mostly Evans pitching. Who is motivated by greed?
- Saw this in a theater in Northern Virginia.